Bu-lat-lat (boo-lat-lat) verb: to search, probe, investigate, inquire; to unearth facts Volume III, Number 49 January 18 - 24, 2004 Quezon City, Philippines |
The
Bayan Muna experience “Politics
of change.” This was the platform that the militant group Bayan Muna carried
in its successful campaign for seats in the House of Representatives. Three
years after and with only a few weeks of sessions left, only two of the bills it
actively supported got passed the labyrinth of intertwining personal and
political interests called Congress and signed into law. So, was Bayan Muna and
its “politics of change” an idea that the dominant and reactionary political
system is not willing to accommodate - yet? BY
ROWENA CARRANZA
|
Bayan Muna Representatives Satur Ocampo (left) and Joel Virador |
Bayan
Muna created history when it topped the party-list elections in 2001,
garnering a vote of 1.7 million and enabling it to have three seats, the
maximum that a party-list group can hold, in the House of Representatives.
It even outvoted the immensely popular Mamamayan
Laban sa Droga (MAD) which had movie idol Richard Gomez as number one
nominee. But since lawmakers are supposed to make laws, the measure of a representative’s effectiveness – and the party-list groups voted – is the number of laws enacted. Of these, Bayan Muna has impressive figures: 44 bills filed and 205 resolutions passed. A majority of the bills however ended up in the congressional trashcan, meaning they are simply referred to the committees concerned, often not even getting past the committee level. A few were able to get to as far as the plenary discussion, even getting support from several congressmen who agreed to |
co-sponsor.
An example is the proposed P125 across the board wage increase. The public then
was hot on the issue of wage increase, given the numerous increases in the
prices of oil and basic commodities. But when the issue died, the proposed bill
was quietly shoved to the bottom of the House agenda.
“It
is mainly the measures proposed by the LEDAC (Legislative-Executive Development
Advisory Council) that get passed,” explained Mike Ac-ac, Rep. Satur
Ocampo’s staff, in an interview with Bulatlat.com.
He said that the presence of a progressive party-list group does not change the
character of the House of Representatives or the Senate.
“It
is still a Congress dominated by the elite, so how can you expect progressive
legislation to be passed here? Certainly, bills that would hurt the interests of
the businessmen and landlords – who comprise 90 percent of the representatives
– would get killed at the very first level,” said Ac-ac.
He
added, “To have two out of 44 bills passed is I think already something to be
proud of. Many spend six years in the Senate and three years in Congress without
sponsoring a bill.”
According
to the House’s official website, the 12th Congress has, as of this
writing, passed only 34 laws, of which only 22 are of major issues.
Amy
Padilla joined Bayan Muna during the campaign period in 2001. Like other
activists, she was excited by the prospect of the Left joining the electoral
struggle. Padilla became one of the legislative staff writers in the office of
Rep. Satur Ocampo, who together with labor leader Crispin Beltran and feminist
activist Liza Maza were the Bayan Muna representatives.
Padilla
came from a Church-based non-government organization while Ac-ac was from the
Ibon Foundation, a research institute that has close ties with progressive
groups. Padilla and Ac-ac are typical of the Bayan Muna representatives’ staff
– activists who came from militant people’s organizations and NGOs.
Interviewed
separately by Bulatlat.com, both
Padilla and Ac-ac talked of their frustrations in their work in Congress.
“Writing
resolutions that you know won’t be passed, drafting House bills that entail so
much research but you know won’t also be passed, as well as the privileged
speeches that are good only for the 10 minutes they are read on the floor and
won’t even be interpellated… it is frustrating,” lamented Padilla. She
said that this is especially true of resolutions that are “touchy,”
particularly human rights issues.
“Even
if you already know that Congress is basically reactionary, that pro-people
measures have no chance of being passed… but still, to see for yourself how a
bill is maimed is so frustrating,” said Padilla.
She
cites as example the impeachment case against Ombudsman Aniano Desierto.
“It’s
a classic case. They said so many things- ‘I read the complaint, etcetera,
etcetera.’ But you know it’s all crap. Not one could give a good reason why
Desierto should not be impeached. It was obvious that it is their interests that
decide how they will vote, not the issues.”
Another
was the bill on compensation for martial law victims, she said. “They did a
blatant sabotage of the bill.”
But
Padilla and Ac-ac note how many people have put their faith on Bayan Muna.
“Many come to the office to ask for advice and support,” said Ac-ac. They
cited cases of peasants who have land problems traveling all the way from the
provinces, persons who were beaten up by policemen and even that of a person who
wanted to have the entire Supreme Court impeached for what she perceived was an
unjust ruling.
Mike
also observed how other legislators were at first wary of the Bayan Muna
representatives. “It was the perceived association with the NPA. And of
course, since more congressmen are from reactionary classes, they are allergic
to perceived leftists. But later on, Bayan Muna was able to build alliances.
Some even volunteered to co-author our bills. They find our issues worth
supporting.”
“One
thing sure is the respect for Bayan Muna. When Bayan Muna speaks of issues,
particularly issues identified with the left, such as the peace talks and the
war, they listen. For example, during hearings on agrarian reform and Ka Satur
is present, they would give him the floor and he would explain the land
problem.”
Ac-ac cited Rep. Roseller Barinaga of Zamboanga who once commented that Bayan Muna representatives are like senators who can speak knowledgeably of national issues, unlike most of the congressmen who are limited to parochial issues of their districts.
Bayan Muna's 3rd National Convention: Advancing the Politics of Change Photo by Arkibong Bayan |
Victories
In
its third national convention held last Jan. 13 at the Bahay ng Alumni in
the University of the Philippines, Diliman, Bayan Muna secretary general
Nathanael Santiago gave a performance report of Bayan Muna.
A matrix of Bayan Muna’s bills and resolutions showed how the group tackled the issues of marginalized sectors such as wage hike, human rights, compensation to victims of human rights violations under the Marcos regime, opposition to water and electricity rates, globalization, US policies, and others. These were supported by mass campaigns, coordinated with other militant groups. |
As
important as the measures they advanced were the measures that the Bayan Muna
representatives opposed. Among these were the Charter Change bill,
Anti-terrorism bill, Special Purpose Assets Vehicles Act, Anti-Money Laundering
Act, and other bills the group believed were as “destructive” and
“anti-people.”
Santiago
also boasted of 673 projects involving health services, livelihood programs,
roads, and school buildings in difference regions.
Ocampo
and the two representatives also spearheaded the lawmakers’ opposition to the
U.S. war, encouraging other legislators to express their opposition through dove
pins and participation in the peace rally organized by Bishop Ted Bacani early
last year in the Rizal Park in Manila. The three were among the legislators who
staged a walkout to protest U.S. President George Bush’s address before a
special joint session of Congress on Oct. 18 last year, joining later the tens
of thousands who took to the streets to protest against U.S. intervention in the
Philippines and the U.S. war on terror.
The
national convention was obviously crucial in preparing Bayan Muna chapters and
members for the coming electoral campaign. And prepare it must, for this time,
the road to electoral victory is going to be more complicated than 2001.
Bayan
Muna would be running this time without the euphoria of Edsa II and with the
Macapagal-Arroyo government now on the other side of the fence. It would also be
competing with other progressive party-list groups (six in all), aside from the
more than a hundred that have applied for accreditation.
And
it is not only the Bayan Muna bills that are being killed. Its members too are
being victimized, with 40 Bayan Muna members killed since 2001, as of Jan. 17.
Ocampo
however is optimistic. He said that the disillusionment of the people with the
Macapagal Arroyo government is pushing them to find alternatives. Bayan Muna, he
said, provides this alternative.
For
the Filipino people, the moment when Macapagal-Arroyo was sworn into office
after the successful and peaceful second Edsa uprising was a moment of hope.
After three years of disappointing rule, marked by corruption, violence and
opportunism, this hope has almost died out.
Bayan
Muna has kept this flickering hope alive. In this regard, it is definitely a
success. Bulatlat.com
We want to know what you think of this article.