The Vatican’s
Enforcer
By John Nichols
The Nation
April 19, 2005
The Sacred College of Cardinals is
supposed to be one of the world's great deliberative bodies.
Yet, despite the many challenges faced
by the Catholic church, the deliberations regarding the selection of a
successor to the late Pope John Paul II put more of an emphasis on speed
and continuity than creative consultation or soul searching.
Barely 24 hours into the first
conclave of its kind in more than a quarter century -- and after only a
handful of votes -- the cardinals settled on the frontrunner for the job:
German Cardinal Joseph Alois Ratzinger.
Past popes have often confounded
expectations, so it difficult to say with certainty that Cardinal
Ratzinger represents a poor choice to lead the world's largest Christian
church.
But all indications suggest that the
cardinals have opted for the most cautious and conservative candidate.
Cardinal Ratzinger, who will now be
identified as Pope Benedict XVI, has for a quarter century been the
church's heavy.
As the prefect since 1981 of the
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the guardian of Catholic
orthodoxy that was formerly known as the Holy Inquisition, he has been
more responsible than anyone except John Paul II for the church's
rejecting of reform and its persecution of progressive thinkers. The group
Catholics for Free Choice notes that, "The cardinal's historic role as a
disciplinarian means the tradition of the punitive father is maintained
within the Roman Catholic church."
As The National Catholic Reporter
reported several years ago, many serious observers of contemporary
Catholicism believe that, "Ratzinger will be remembered as the architect
of John Paul's internal Kulturkampf, intimidating and punishing thinkers
in order to restore a model of church -- clerical, dogmatic and rule-bound
-- many hoped had been swept away by the Second Vatican Council, the
1962-65 assembly of bishops that sought to renew Catholicism and open it
to the world. Ratzinger's campaign bears comparison to the anti-modernist
drive in the early part of the century or Pius XII's crackdown in the
1950s, critics say, but is even more disheartening because it followed a
moment of such optimism and new life."
It was Ratzinger who laid the
groundwork in the early 1980s for the crackdown of the Liberation Theology
movement, which sought to identify the church more closely with the
struggles of the poor. And it was Ratzinger who, in 1985, silenced
Franciscan Father Leonardo Boff, arguably the most prominent proponent of
efforts to put the church on the side of the Latin American workers and
farmers who were seeking a fairer distribution of the region's resources,
a fuller democracy and a brighter future for their children.
Ratzinger's modern-day inquisition
against Boff and his followers moved a church that had seemed to be
entering a new era back toward its most reactionary roots. And it did not
end when Boff disappeared into a Franciscan monastery in Brazil.
Over the years that followed,
Ratzinger led drives to punish moral theologians who embraced religious
pluralism and encouraged dialogue within the church. Liberal Catholics in
the U.S. well remember Ratzinger's moves to undermine American bishops who
sought to find a place in the church for gays and lesbians such as
Archbishop Raymond Hunthausen of Seattle, who was also a leading critic of
the Reagan administration's support for military juntas and death squads
in Latin America.
As the National Catholic Reporter's
John Allen Jr. noted in 1999, in an article on Ratzinger headlined, "The
Vatican's Enforcer": At the most basic level, many Catholics cannot escape
the sense that Ratzinger's exercise of ecclesial power is not what Jesus
had in mind."
It was his awareness of Ratzinger's
record that led Father Andrew Greeley, one of the American church's most
prominent thinkers, to observe before the Cardinals began Monday voting
that, "I'd be dismayed if Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the church's official
heresy hunter for a long time, is the next pope."
Now, it seems that the best hope is
that papal tendency to defy expectation -- that the Vatican's enforcer
will pull a "Nixon goes to China" and become the church's modernizer.
Father Greeley says, "Maybe a Papa
Ratzinger can change, too." For the sake of the church, and the world that
is so frequently influenced by it, let us pray that Greeley's words prove
to be more than wishful thinking.
Reposted by Bulatlat
BACK TO TOP ■
COMMENT
© 2004 Bulatlat
■ Alipato Publications
Permission is granted to reprint or redistribute this article, provided its author/s and Bulatlat are properly credited and notified.