Behind the barrage of official information from Malacanang and concerned government agencies, what did Aquino and his clan do in Hacienda Luisita?
Contributed by Luisita Watch*
President Benigno Simeon “Noynoy” Aquino III and his clan continue to hold on to their precious Hacienda Luisita, the highly-controversial sugar estate in Tarlac province, Central Luzon which has been in the clutches of the Aquino-Cojuangco clan since the late 1950s.
Like his mother, former President Corazon “Cory” Cojuangco-Aquino, Aquino promised social justice and land reform in Hacienda Luisita during his electoral campaign some six years ago. And just like those of his mother‘s, Aquino’s actions have all proven contradictory to such promise. In fact, there‘s enough reason to believe that he did everything in his power to subvert the landmark Supreme Court (SC) ruling for total land distribution in Hacienda Luisita.
Farmworkers can be fairly blunt about it: Aquino‘s purported land reform accomplishments in Hacienda Luisita are all freaking lies propagated by the president‘s loyal and well-paid cabal of yellow zombies, trolls, and spin doctors.
Behind the barrage of official information from Malacanang and concerned government agencies, what did Aquino and his clan do in Hacienda Luisita?
1. Pushing the compromise deal (2010)
Aquino‘s first order of business as haciendero (landlord) president was to keep silent on his family‘s sly maneuvers to bring the oppressive Stock Distribution Option (SDO) scheme back on track in Hacienda Luisita. Remember the SDO? It was when ?the farmworkers, as stockholders, received the paltry sum of P9.50 per day for the backbreaking task of cutting and hauling sugarcane.
In August 2010, acts of bribery and fraud led to the signing of the Hacienda Luisita “compromise deal” between the management of the Hacienda Luisita, Inc. (HLI) and a handful of former union leaders who misrepresented the thousands of Luisita farmworkers as being amenable to bringing the SDO back. Aquino immediately distanced himself from the controversy by giving a token statement that the matter was “intra-corporate dispute,” and that he had divested his shares in HLI after assuming the presidency in June 2010.
2. Securing the Corona conviction (2012)?
Aquino‘s much hyped, anti-corruption crusade to have former Chief Justice Renato Corona impeached and convicted is Aquino‘s first step to retain control of Hacienda Luisita. Corona, a midnight appointee of despised former president Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, was the principal proponent of the April 24, 2012 Supreme Court (SC) decision ordering the distribution of Hacienda Luisita to farmworker-beneficiaries.
Corona was handed the guilty verdict in May, barely a month after the SC issued its final and executory decision for total land distribution in Hacienda Luisita.
Corona’s conviction has largely been hailed at the onset as a major accomplishment of his “daang matuwid” (righteous path) campaign. The trial however would soon be exposed as an ugly act of reprisal involving millions of taxpayers‘ money coursed through the illegal Disbursement Acceleration Program (DAP) purportedly used by Aquino to bribe Senator-judges for an assured guilty verdict.
3. Springboarding Oplan April Spring (2011 to present)
Is anyone even aware that the HLI still owes their “stockholders” – the farmworkers – a staggering Php 1.33 billion? The audit of these assets – proceeds from the sale of 80 hectares traversed by SCTEX and a 500- hectare disputed property – is among the provisions of the 2012 SC decision. Of late, the SC has appointed three auditors to take on this job but HLI, Department of Agrarian Reform and the Aquino administration have so far succeeded in delaying the process.
This kind of deception coupled with bribery and violence form part of Oplan April Spring, a special operations campaign to discredit the farmers‘ struggle and to project the landlords as pro-poor and pro- development. This plan was hatched by the Aquino-Cojuangcos and RCBC, a Yuchengco-owned commercial bank claiming ownership of the disputed property.
From 2011 to 2013, security agents, goons and local police engaged in violent attacks to destroy the farmers? bungkalan or land cultivation initiative in the area. After the ensuing barrage of threats, criminal suits and pay-offs, RCBC managed to fence off the property. A few local leaders succumbed to bribery, but the pressure only tempered the rest of the farmworkers to carry on with the fight.
Today, farmworkers continue to expose this unpaid debt amid the plan to build a solar power plant within the disputed RCBC property. This public-private partnership (PPP) project between the President, Department of Energy and Petrogreen, a sister company of RCBC, conceals landgrabbing behind a purportedly environment-friendly endeavor while ensuring further corporate profits at the expense of the displaced community.
4. Toying with “tambiolo” land reform (2013)
The lot allocation through lottery drum (tambiolo) raffle made fools out of farmworkers in a manner too crass to even be considered funny by the makers of our favorite noon-time shows. The farce, however, which the DAR brought to each of the ten Luisita villages could have passed for your usual government carnival if not for the fact that the road show also featured the intimidating presence of state forces in full battle gear – long firearms, fire trucks for dispersals, jail buses for arrests. Farmworkers were practically made to participate at gunpoint.
The DAR enjoyed maximum logistical support and media mileage for Aquino‘s land reform which has indeed been quite expeditious – expeditiously bogus, that is. More irregularities include:
anomalous land survey and reduced land area allocated to beneficiaries;
exclusion of a number of bonafide farmworkers in the final masterlist of beneficiaries and the ?underhanded insertion of names of unqualified ones;
inept facilitation of the audit of Php 1.33 billion that HLI owes farmworkers;
inaction on the coverage of all agricultural lands in Luisita claimed by TADECO, Central Azucarera de ?Tarlac (CAT) and other Cojuangco firms, including the appeal for revocation of a conversion ordercovering 500 hectares under RCBC, LIPCO and Lusita Realty Corporation (LRC).
overpriced landlord compensation to the Aquino-Cojuangcos amounting to P 451.7 million
compulsory signing of promissory notes (Application to Purchase and Farmers Undertaking or ?APFU) to ensure amortization payments;
?Luisita farmers are clamoring for free land distribution, a just demand given the history of the estate.
5. Bulldozing spree (2013 to present)
Two days before Christmas 2013, Luisita farmworkers were picketing in front of the Philippine National Police (PNP) Camp Macabulos in Tarlac City to demand the release of illegally arrested and detained farmers. When the farmers finally emerged from the facility, one was burning with fever, another was nursing a black eye. They were nabbed and slapped with physical injuries complaints but they were the ones clearly battered by authorities. A photo of a farmer being manhandled by police even went viral online, compelling mainstream press to temporarily dispense with the unwritten protocol of blacking out news on the continuing struggle for justice in Hacienda Luisita.
Weeks before, Aquino-Cojuangco goons employed by the Tarlac Development Corporation (Tadeco) fenced off a 260-hectare area in Balete village, destroying huts and bulldozing crops to forcibly evict farmers. The “landgrab spree” did not end there. On February 8, 2014, the exact date of Aquino‘s birthday, worse atrocities were committed. Huts were burned down, farm tools and animals looted, children were maltreated and detained, and the remaining crops were completely wiped out. In the months to come, even DAR employees and village officials were involved in violent incidents in other villages such as Cutcut, Asturias and Mapalacsiao.
The victims, ordinary farmers, peasant leaders and advocates were charged with false criminal complaints and harassment suits. The farmers did file counter-charges several times at the Department of Justice (DOJ), but these, as may be expected, have only been gathering dust.
6. Crowning the Aryendo Queen (2014 to present)
Even before the DAR‘s implementation of the “tambiolo” land reform, the Aquino-Cojuangcos have already coerced farmers to enter into leaseback deals brokered primarily by the Luisita Estate Management (LEM), a group of “yellow agents” and former HLI supervisors formed to thwart the farmers‘ bungkalan. Subsequently, the chaos caused by the tambiolo scheme naturally complemented this maneuver to reconcentrate land back to the control of landlords. Instead of ensuring the farmers‘ right to own and till, papers awarded to beneficiaries only served as collateral in the rampant unlawful leaseback operations called aryendo.
Yes, Virginia, illicit leaseback deals in Luisita have been so clandestinely complex and would have gone unnoticed by the public if not for…Virginia Torres. After Torres‘s stint at the Land Transportation Office (LTO) was cut short by a viral video showing her playing the slot machine, the Casino Queen and Presidential Kabarilan (shooting buddy) was crowned by Aquino as Aryendo Queen of Hacienda Luisita. Torres set up her reign in Mapalacsiao village, where she controls at least 200 hectares for sugarcane production through measly lease offers of P7,500 a year to cash-strapped beneficiaries. Those who refused or got in her way faced the wrath of tractors razing farmers‘ food crops to the ground.
Recently, Aquino and Torres inadvertently admitted to their collusion in the aryendo modus as they foolishly attempted to exonerate themselves from yet another scandal – sugar smuggling. The DAR‘s sugar blockfarming program and its Agrarian Reform Beneficiaries Organizations are seen as fronts to conceal the aryendo and buying of farmlots. (Unfair land deals are practically legal with CARP, but that‘s another story.)
7. Burning bridges with the azucarera? (2014 to present)
Presidential sister Kris Aquino at one time quite cheerfully told Luisita farmworkers that ?they can burn her anytime. As one of the directors of the CAT sugar mill, Kris’s effigy was among those burned by angry farmworkers who stormed the DAR on April 24, 2014, two years after the sham implementation of the SC decision. CAT is one of the Cojuangco-Aquino?s “corporate avatars” engaged in landgrabbing. Kris was rather glad the effigy-burning put her, as she said, at par with US President Obama. The TV queen‘s comparison may just have been right on the money— her family‘s infamous legacy of strafing farmers with machine guns sounds equally disturbing as Obama‘s policy of dropping bombs on villages via drones.
Kris and rest of the clan – Uncle Peping (Jose Cojuangco Jr ) and Aunt Tingting especially– would then make it appear that they no longer want anything to do with the azucarera. A few months after Kris got burnt, her family sold their shares to businessman Martin Lorenzo. Lorenzo established the CAT Resource and Asset Holdings, Inc. or CRAHI which also acquired shares from LRC, LIPCO and other such corporate incarnations of the Aquino-Cojuangco’s cacique avarice.
In May this year, almost 700 CAT workers were retrenched and forced to sign “voluntary retirement” papers due to new management policy. Lorenzo and Fernando Cojuangco, the Presidential cousin who remains at the helm of CAT, plan to further dispose of CAT’s and LRC’s land assets. Are the Cojuangcos really burning bridges with Hacienda Luisita? Or are they just, true to form, expertly covering up the tracks of these new instances of exploitation and further reducing the prospects for a truthful audit of their P1.33 billion debt to farmworkers?
8. Greasing Luisita with DAP (2013-present)
Florencio “Butch” Abad must really be cherished by the Aquino-Cojuangcos. He was a DAR secretary during Cory’s time when SDO was imposed in Hacienda Luisita. As Aquino‘s budget secretary, he is credited with inventing the Disbursement Acceleration Program (DAP)or what has also been known to the public as ?presidential pork barrel and which the SC has already declared unconstitutional.
From 2011 to 2013, Aquino and Abad, through the DAP, were able to pool in a mind-boggling P237 billion in so-called savings. From this amount, P144 billion became funds for projects while the rest drifted to pork barrel oblivion. Spending of these discretionary funds depended entirely on “good faith” and it was assumed that the people have actually entrusted this colossal amount of taxpayer‘s money to this porky tandem.
So how much of DAP was used to grease Hacienda Luisita? Mudslinging among trapos (traditional politicians) revealed that acquiescent Senator-judges were supposedly allotted P50 million each to ensure the guilty verdict in the Corona impeachment. DAR later admitted that P451.7 million landlord compensation granted to Aquino-Cojuangcos was also sourced from DAP.
Aquino also disbursed P3.5 million in DAP for a small multi-purpose hall in Barangay Central, Hacienda Luisita, said to be a favor to his pet Barangay Captain Edgardo Aguas, also an alleged broker of the aryendo. Concreting of dirt roads is still in full swing in Luisita, a big help to sugar dummies and land speculators hoping to dupe more farmer-beneficiaries into entering illicit deals.
9. Noynoying: Just being his haciendero self
Nobody can effortlessly demolish the Daang Matuwid delusion via the Hacienda Luisita route better than Aquino himself. The President even earned the “Noynoying” tag from youth protesters in reference to his trademark sluggish response to issues of national importance. “Noynoying” even set the internet ablaze with nasty memes sharply critical of Aquino‘s infamous ?work ethic.
Some progressives would point out however that “Noynoying” is not at all about passivity or just a state of affairs pertaining to Aquino’s unique brand of sloth or lack of sympathy. Noynoying, or just being his own haciendero self, is actually an out-and-out active performance of his duty to advance and protect the political and economic class interests of landlords, big business and foreign plunderers. We see this clearly from Luisita to Lianga, where peasants face state-sponsored landgrabbing, repression and killings.
Let‘s look at government land reform policy. The Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) which was enacted by Cory Aquino in 1988 finally expired after several failed extension programs on June 30, 2014, under the current Aquino regime. CARP enabled the oppressive SDO scheme then. CARP is now the DAR‘s justification for tambiolo land reform. Aquino can always claim he can‘t do anything about the bulldozing or the farmworkers’ appeal for free land distribution, he‘s just there to implement existing policy. That‘s how he can go full “Noynoying” on land reform.
The result: after decades of bogus land reform, nine out of ten farmers are now landless, or tilling land they do not own.
10. Murdering the Luisita massacre case (2010 & 2014)
The Hacienda Luisita massacre case filed before the Office of the Ombudsman by more than 50 survivors and relatives in January 2005, was murdered twice under Aquino.
Aquino, a congressman and active administrator of the estate during the November 16, 2004 massacre, is one of the respondents in the case. Aquino,and other civilian respondents such as former Labor Secretary Patricia Sto. Tomas, were immediately cleared of charges in July 2005.
The case against police and military respondents, however, was silently junked by the Ombudsman only a few months into Aquino‘s presidency. The Ombudsman’s Military and Law Enforcement Offices dismissed all charges against police and military respondents in December 2010, based solely on reports from the National Bureau of Investigation and without any effort to conduct a more thorough investigation.
In August 2014, survivors and relatives of the victims filed a motion to reopen the case. The motion was junked only a few months later in October.
Instead of being prosecuted, military officials involved in the Hacienda Luisita massacre were promoted by Aquino into juicy posts. Recently retired AFP Chief, Gen. Gregorio Pio Catapang, was one of the ground commanders during the violent dispersal, along with Gen. Ricardo Visaya who now holds the reins in the AFP Southern Luzon Command. Under Aquino, even hitmen went scot-free – Pfc. Roderick U. Dela Cruz, the soldier implicated in the killing of Central Azucarera de Tarlac Labor Union (CATLU) President Ricardo Ramos in 2005, was acquitted in December 2013.
11 Years of Injustice and Impunity
It‘s been eleven years since the Hacienda Luisita massacre of November 16, 2004.
*Images by Luisita Watch. Luisita Watch network was convened in 2014 by supporters of Hacienda Luisita farmers.